Many of the people who originally settled in the Middle Rio Grande area migrated into the area from the Four Corners area during the 1200s and 1300s. It is felt that the Tiwa language began to significantly diverge from Tewa around 1400 CE when the people were moving down out of the Jemez Mountains and off the Pajarito Plateau, separating into villages in the valley of the Rio Grande. That movement was forced by a drought worse than the famous Great Drought of 1275-1296. That same drought in the late 1300s also forced the people of Zuni to abandon some of their newer settlements and rebuild some of their old pueblos along the Zuni River.
When Coronado and his men arrived in 1540, there were maybe 20,000 people living in the Tiwa pueblos of the Middle Rio Grande. Coronado first sacked Kuaua, then he attacked all the other nearby pueblos looking for food and gold. Then he moved on to Pecos Pueblo (Cicuyé) where he spent several months while some of his troops went exploring further, looking for gold. On his return through the Middle Rio Grande a year later, he was denied entry to any pueblos and was harrassed all the way through the region until he was gone back to Zuni.
The Spanish didn't come back until Don Juan de Oñaté came north with his troops in 1598. By then, Spanish diseases had taken their toll and the 12 or 13 large Tiwa pueblos in the area had been reduced to 2: Isleta and Alameda.
In 1617 the Mission of San Francisco was built at Alameda and in 1680, the people of Alameda were prominent in the Pueblo Revolt of 1680. The Spanish came back in 1681, 1688 and 1692, each time attacking the pueblo and burning the village before being forced back to Mexico by warriors from other pueblos. Those who escaped each attack on Alameda fled to Hopi and resettled in the village of Payupki. After each attack some returned but after the Spanish reoccupation in 1692, they all abandoned Alameda and moved to Payupki.
In November of 1742, about 440 of the Tiwas came back from Payupki. At Payupki they had developed a good business making pottery and distributing it locally. That with water and farmland problems were causing aggravation with their nearby Second Mesa neighbors: their welcome was wearing thin. They were finally convinced to return to the Middle Rio Grande by a group of Franciscan priests who made promises to them that the Spanish authorities ignored. They petitioned the Spanish governor to be allowed to resettle their former lands but their requests went nowhere for years, until they were able to convince a new Spanish priest to submit the documents again. Then the Sandia people were subject to regular raids from the Comanche, Kiowa, Apache and Navajo as the site they reoccupied was directly in the path taken by most raiders headed for the Spanish settlements.
In 1748 permission to resettle near the site of their old pueblo was granted, with the first requirement being construction of a new mission. However, that effort was thwarted by Spanish settlers conscripting the Sandias to perform other work on their privately-owned farms.
On May 24, 1762, Governor Tomas Cachupin ordered the Pueblo of Sandia to be completely rebuilt and that no Indians were to be worked as laborers for Spanish farmers until the pueblo and church were completely reconstructed. Then the Sandias were allowed to reoccupy their pueblo to create a better "buffer" against the Navajo, Apache, Kiowa and Comanche who enjoyed raiding the village of Albuquerque.
In 1775, Sandia, acting as that buffer, lost 30 people in an attack by the Comanche. The Comanche also attacked Santa Fe in force that year. Those events caused Governor Juan Bautista de Anza to lead Spanish militia into Colorado and engage with the Comanche there. The Battle of Cuerno Verde ended with most of the Comanche command structure dead and the power of the Comanche severely reduced. However, between the Navajo, Apache and small bands of Comanche and Kiowa, Sandia was constantly being raided until a truce was eventually struck near "Poi Pa Huth" or "Friendship Arroyo" in the Placitas area.
Sandia had a pottery tradition before the 1680 revolt but it seems to have reached its peak at Payupki. Very little of that tradition survived the trip back to the Rio Grande Valley, never mind the next 200 years. When John Montoya decided he wanted to revive the Sandia tradition, he had to go off-pueblo to learn. That revival didn't last long as John didn't last long either and no one else seemed to be interested: the money coming out of Sandia Resort & Casino has essentially stopped most work on the pueblo that requires that kind of attention, patience and labor. That said, next to the site of the casino, the Sandias operate the Bien Mur Indian Market Center representing Arts and Crafts from all the pueblos.